$935,275.80 Verdict For Railroad Employee
Dorrance v. Union Pacific Railroad, Multnomah County Case No. 14CV07336
Plaintiff Dorrance was an employee of defendant Union Pacific Railroad. He brought this claim under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act which governs on-the-job injuries for railroad employees rather than worker’s compensation laws. The Act allows Dorrance to sue his employer for negligently causing him injury.
Dorrance was working at a switching location when he fell. He alleged that the location’s walkway was unsafe due to large rocks and debris and no lighting. He also argued that his employer violated Oregon railroad walkway safety standards. He claimed that the fall caused him injuries including a disc herniation at L5/S1 and injury to adjacent nerve roots. His doctor did not believe he was a surgical candidate. He underwent extensive care before finally having a spinal cord stimulator implanted. He alleged that his injury prevented him from returning to work and that his pain is permanent.
Union Pacific Railroad argued that Dorrance was responsible for his injury for failing to keep a lookout, failing to inspect his work area before working and failing to plan his work to prevent injury. They also disputed the cause and extent of Dorrance’s injury and alleged that Dorrance did not mitigate his damages.
Plaintiff’s Counsel – Bradley Wahrlich
Defense Counsel – Timothy Coleman
Verdict – $935,275.80 (Verdict was $1,159,148, but the jury found Dorrance 15% at fault and also that he failed to mitigate $50,000 in damages)
Date – April 8, 2016April 20, 2016